Not A Bug Alchemy BODs

[Omalley]

This is strange.. based on other bods, alchemy bods seem off..


The 3 part bods are worth 300 turn in, or 60 banked points.

Yet..


The 4 part BOD is worth only 250 Turn in, and 50 Bank...

I would think that the 4 part would be 300/60, and the 3 part would be 250/50

- As i was writing this i decided to go back and check the 5 and 6 part bods too.. and they seem off as well..


5 part 450/90


6 part 400/80

Again, it would make more sense if these values were switched as well.

-Once again, while writing this is decided to check the 10 and 15 large bods as well:

Both 10 & 15 count larges seem to follow suit, 3s are worth more than 4s, and 5s are worth more than 6s. The small bods seem fine, they increase in the amount of points, based on difficulty.

 

[Omalley]

Decided to take a quick look back at alchemy.. the differences between value and count, and when checking the 3 part 10, 15, & 20s this is what i found

As you can see here, the 10, is worth more than the 15 & the 20..

 

[Omalley]

Okay, i think i figured this one out.. since there is no such thing as an exceptional potion, it seems that alchemy bod reward points are based on the strength of the potion.




checking the same bod, just different counts, shows a proper point value based on strength of the potion.. not the amount to craft "lesser", "greater" ect. So this is not a bug.. im guessing.

 

[Dan]

Yeah, there are OSI tables out there somewhere. I do not think any of these are bugs unless you can point me to some specific literature or we get an OSI BOD guru to compare one of the ones in question to one on EA.